In short
A bath with a door replaces the existing bathtub, which means it requires major renovations. A bath lift chair usually integrates with the current tub with limited interventions. When choosing between a bath with a door vs. a bath lift chair, the real question is this: do you want to renovate, or simply make getting into the tub safer?

What work is required for a bathtub with a door?
A bathtub with a door comes to replace the old tub. You have to remove the existing tub, connect the plumbing, redo waterproofing, and finish surfaces, often including tile work.
Sécur-O-Bain estimates this project between $10,000 and $20,000, installation included.
The installation then stays with the home at resale. Day to day, the user gets in before running the water and waits for the drain to empty before getting out.
In short: A bathtub with a door is a permanent solution that generally fits into a renovation project.
What work is required for a bath lift chair?
The Sécur-O-Bain bath lift leaves the bathtub in place. The mast is secured between the floor and ceiling, with no need to touch plumbing or tiles. According to the manufacturer, an installer can set it up in under two hours. A handy person can do it in 3 to 4 hours with the assembly plan.
As for the work required, between a bath with a door vs. a bath lift chair, the latter clearly comes out the winner. You do have to check floor clearance for pivoting, ceiling height (84 to 101 in., up to 120 in. with an extension), and the bathtub model.
In short: The bath lift chair keeps the tub in place and limits the scope of work required.

Bathtub with a door vs. bath lift chair: comparison table
Here are the criteria that really weigh in the choice between a bathtub with a door vs. a bath lift chair.
Criteria | Bathtub with a door | Sécur-O-Bain bath lift chair |
|---|---|---|
Work | Replacement, plumbing, finish work | Floor-to-ceiling fastening, no plumbing |
Lead time | Renovation project to plan | Delivery in 5 to 10 business days, installed in under 2 h |
Indicative cost | $10,000 to $20,000 installed** | $5,495 + shipping, or $6,500 installed* |
Independence | Entry through the door, no stepping over | Seated transfer, powered lowering and lifting |
Caregiver access | High walls, limited access | Caregiver stays outside the tub, can hold the controller |
Wait time | Filling and draining once seated | None. Tub is filled in advance |
Relocation | No | Yes, without damaging tilework |
Keeping the bathtub | No | Yes, the seat lifts to free the tub |
Compatibility | Depends on space and plumbing | Depends on ceiling height, clearance, and the bathtub |
*These are the prices available on the manufacturer’s website at the time of research. They are subject to change without notice. **Range taken from the comparison published by Sécur-O-Bain. The actual cost varies by model and scope of work.
In short: Beyond the purchase price, the total cost includes work, lead time, and what happens to the equipment if you move.
Which solution fits your situation?
Bathtub with a door or bath lift chair? It depends on your home project and your mobility:
- Full renovation already planned: the bath with a door fits into the project.
- Renter or possible move: the lift comes with you, the bath with a door stays.
- Attachment to a traditional tub: the lift leaves the bathtub intact for the family.
- Caregiver present: the lift lets them stay outside the tub and manage the controller.
- Changing mobility: you can add a leg lift or armrests later.
If immersion matters less than transfer safety, the question becomes: transfer bench or bath lift chair?
In short: The right choice depends as much on your home plans and evolving mobility as on immediate needs.
Why is Sécur-O-Bain an alternative to consider before renovating?
Before spending $10,000 or more to decide between a bathtub with a door or a bath lift chair, check whether your tub can simply be equipped. The Sécur-O-Bain bath lift chair combines pivoting and lifting, can be relocated without damaging tiling, and is assembled in Laval. Alain Desmarais, the company’s founder, designed it for his mother. He felt adapted installations were overpriced for most families.
The product is non-taxable, a tax credit may apply for those 70 and over in Québec, and the structure is guaranteed for 5 years. For anyone satisfied with washing while seated, it is still worth weighing a shower chair against a bath lift first.
In short: Sécur-O-Bain is particularly well suited to making access safer without having to transform the entire bathroom.
FAQ
Yes, in most cases. The old bathtub is removed, the new model is connected, then waterproofing and finishes are redone.
Yes. That is the Sécur-O-Bain approach, compatible with most standard bathtubs depending on clearance and ceiling height.
The bath lift, which can be taken apart and reinstalled. Between a bath with a door vs. a bath lift chair, the chair is the only one that can be relocated.
Both avoid the need to step over the rim. A bath with a door does require waiting for filling and draining, which delays exit in case of discomfort. The lift raises you as soon as you activate the controller.
Attach a photo of your tub area to your free quote request. The detailed estimate arrives within 48 hours, with no obligation, so you can compare a bathtub with a door or a bath lift with the real cost in hand.
Sources
- Bath Lift Chair | Sécur-O-Bain
- How to choose a walk-in bathtub: prices, benefits and drawbacks | Sécur-O-Bain
- The Best Bath Chair: Bath Products Comparison | Sécur-O-Bain
- Bath Lift Chairs for People with Reduced Mobility | Sécur-O-Bain
- Bath Lift Chair for the Elderly in Quebec (About Us) | Sécur-O-Bain
- Free Quote | Sécur-O-Bain
